Skip to content

Comparative Analysis

Two of these peers are cited by the director; the rest are the obvious solvers of the same problems.

Stated influences

Overland (Finji, 2019) — Simić names it as "a helpful encouragement" for the combination of road trip and turn-based combat. Both games alternate a vehicle journey with small tactical boards, both use a rotating cast, and both let characters leave. Overland goes further in one direction Highwater refuses: it makes the journey a resource problem (fuel, seats, who you can afford to save) and lets characters be lost through play rather than through script. Highwater keeps the road-movie shape and removes the survival economy, which is why its journey is atmosphere where Overland's is agony.

Mutant Year Zero: Road to Eden (The Bearded Ladies, 2018) — named as "in the back of our minds", and the closest structural sibling: a post-apocalyptic party crossing ruins between authored encounters, with real-time exploration and character-defining abilities. MYZ retains XP, gear tiers, silent takedowns and hit percentages. Highwater keeps the shape and strips the RPG spine — exactly the difference Simić flagged when he said a future turn-based project would add "more RPG elements with an evolution of characters over time."

Unstated but instructive

Into the Breach (Subset, 2018) — the canonical no-randomness tactics game: perfect information, telegraphed enemy intent, displacement as the primary verb, and objectives that are usually "protect", not "kill". Highwater shares the determinism and the shove-things-into-hazards core, but not the perfect information: Into the Breach shows every enemy's next action, while Highwater's enemy turn is only implicitly predictable. Adding intent telegraphs would have cost Highwater almost nothing and made its puzzles fully legible — the highest-value borrow available to it.

XCOM (Firaxis) — the reference every reviewer reaches for, and the wrong one. XCOM's identity is percentage risk, permadeath, squad building and a strategic layer; Highwater has none of these. The comparison persists because of camera and grid, and it damages the game — players arrive expecting a build loop and find a puzzle book.

Fire Emblem / Final Fantasy Tactics — invoked by reviewers for the story-driven cast with fixed personalities. The gap is progression: those games make each character a growth investment, so losing one hurts as a sunk cost. Highwater has the loss without the investment (Party & Characters).

Dredge (Black Salt Games, 2023) — the nearest neighbour in this vault: same era, same boat-and-islands loop, same small-indie scale, opposite philosophy. Dredge prices everything against time and makes the crossing itself the decision; Highwater has no economy and makes the crossing a mood. Comparing the two is the cleanest available demonstration that boat traversal is not inherently boring or interesting — it is whichever the surrounding economy makes it.

What is actually distinctive

Stripping away everything shared with the peers above, three things are Highwater's own:

  1. The environment as the whole tactical vocabulary. Not props as a bonus layer (XCOM's destructible cover, MYZ's explosive barrels) but props as the primary source of solutions, with character verbs as the smaller half.
  2. Water as an omnipresent instant-removal edge. A flooded setting makes displacement the strongest verb in the game from minute one and keeps it strong to the end — a genuinely novel case of theme dictating tactics.
  3. A diegetic radio as the pacing engine, carried over from a previous game in the same universe and sold as its own product. Rare outside Rockstar-scale budgets, and here done by a small team as a primary rather than ambient channel (Radio & Audio).

Combat · Environmental Interaction · Tensions & Lessons · Return to Earth Universe