Skip to content

Boat & Navigation

Half the runtime is spent driving a rubber dinghy across flooded ruins. The boat has no fuel, no upgrades, no durability and no combat role. It is a pacing device, not a system.

The verbs

  • Triggers accelerate, left stick steers, right stick moves the camera (console); a virtual thumbstick on mobile, which reviewers found the weakest part of the touch port
  • Navigation is by a minimalist compass ring in the corner with a dot for the next objective — no map screen while sailing, no waypoint list
  • Landfall switches the game to an isometric third-person scene where you walk, talk, and interact with sparkling objects to scavenge
  • One or two optional islands are flagged per chapter; everything else is scenery

There is no fast travel and no open world: each chapter is a segmented stretch of water with a fixed set of stops (World & Chapter Structure).

What the sailing is for

  1. Tone regulation. The fights are slapstick; the sailing is melancholy. Alternating them is what keeps the apocalypse from reading as either grim or glib (Narrative & Theme).
  2. A delivery channel for the radio. Highwater Pirate Radio needs uninterrupted listening time, and open water is the only place the game can spend it (Radio & Audio).
  3. Scale. Half-sunk brutalist blocks read as enormous only if you spend time passing them at boat speed. The environmental art is the game's most praised asset and this is its display case.

The friction it creates

This is the most consistently criticised part of the game, and the criticism is structural rather than a bug:

  • Empty seas. "Highwater's seas feel empty" (Hardcore iOS); "there is a lot of downtime between interactions" (Gaming Age); one player report calls the opening sail a near-quit moment.
  • Backtracking across featureless water with no shortcut (Games Asylum).
  • A HUD that under-communicates. The compass ring is easy to miss; cleared objectives reportedly keep their dots, so the player cannot tell finished content from pending (UI & Information Design).

Downtime without a second channel

Dredge solves the same problem — long, slow boat traversal — by making the trip itself cost the master resource, so every minute at sea is a decision. Highwater has no resource to spend, so its traversal cannot be decision-bearing; it is bet entirely on the radio and the view. When the radio track is one the player doesn't like, the design has no fallback.

What breaks if you remove it

Cut the sailing and the fights arrive back to back, the radio has nowhere to play, and the world stops being the protagonist the director says it is. Compress it — shorter legs, a skip, or a second thing to do while sailing — and most reviews' central complaint disappears. That trade is the clearest "what I would change" in this analysis (Tensions & Lessons).

Core Loop · Radio & Audio · World & Chapter Structure · UI & Information Design